Though both labels come from the same Montreal-based design team, I can't help but favour Soia & Kyo, pictured below.

Soia & Kyo 'Millie' Double-Breasted Trenchcoat - $224
Soia & Kyo 'Eliana' Coat - $325
Mackage 'Filippa' Coat - $660

Mackage 'Jessy Ann' Short Coat - $495
Mackage does have the one-up in the chic but cozy sweater department though.Mackage 'Amira' Sweater Cardigan - $363